Yep, my oldest had made a homemade pumpkin pie and for whatever reason it didn't quite set up all the way, though we were pretty sure it was done. It had more of a custard texture. The flavor was incredible, but she wasn't happy. Her solution? Buy some vanilla ice cream and create a milkshake. For reals!
Vanilla ice cream
Leftover Pumpkin Pie (including the crust)
Simply place pie pieces, ice cream and milk in a blender and blend till smooth. Eyeball your quantities. The flavor is seriously like drinking a piece of pie...I loved it! Go make it!!!
With Joy UNquenchable,